143 Comments

TECHNICAL GLITCH (AND ALMOST CERTAINLY USER AKA AHP ERROR) —> links didn’t make it into paid subscribers’ emails. My apologies, and look out for them in Tuesday’s thread prompt!

Expand full comment

As a longtime high school English teacher I often struggled to keep my own reading interests alive. I think I went through a drought of about a decade once, where all I did was reread the novels I was assigning to my students. Pandemic had the opposite effect on me: I read and read and read. I read almost 40 books between the shutdown and the end of 2020 and maintained that pace afterward. There was a theme in those books: a lot of running books, a lot of books about racism, and a lot of books about survival such as Endurance by Alfred Lansing. I needed to understand the world I was living in. Since my divorce in 2021 I have read a lot of books about women’s rights, and about solitude, and about nature; you can guess, based on those, how I’ve been spending my time. “Proving” that reading is important? I have a former student who was a wonderful reader and thinker. She had a terrible home situation and all of us teachers hoped and dreamed that she was going to “make it out.” But two nights before graduation she committed a terrible crime and is now in the state women’s prison for 20+ years. I’ve started writing to her and learned I can order books for her. So I think we will read some books together and talk about them via pen and paper, very much like...and not at all like...the old days.

Expand full comment

I am so sorry to hear about your student. I know that it's very distant from me, but I wish there was some word for the grief that people experience in situations like this. Either the death of a student, or a friend or some other kind of terrible circumstance befalling someone that is not "technically" related to us, but someone in our world, with whom we develop close ties. Wishing you and her the best in your literature endeavors. Damn, damn, damn.

Expand full comment

I don’t even have words for this but just want you to know I’ll be thinking of her 🧡

Expand full comment

I worked in corrections for eight years. Sending books is going to be a real and lasting gift to the young woman you wrote about. I've seen it myself just working in a county jail. Books are everything in a carceral living situation. I hope you follow that instinct and I think it's lovely that you thought of it.

Expand full comment

There are wonderful organizations that publish incarcerated residents that I think really helps writers break up the fear and boredom and shame of day to day prison life.

Prison Journalism Project

Humans of San Quentin

Expand full comment

Books were first how I learned English. Being able to read was one of the first things I remember being praised for. I was a Vietnamese immigrant at a Catholic school in Florida, where the disgruntled nun who was teaching me, disapproved of everything about me (poor, not Catholic, not white), but was amazed that I could read better than the other kids. Books are how I learned how to be in the world. I was painfully shy and introverted, so I read books to try to figure out how to make friends. I tried on being as willful and precocious as Anne and Anne of Green Gables. When I couldn't figure out how to explain myself, I handed my friends books that might help them understand me better. I wasn't terribly original: I made a middle school boyfriend read The Bell Jar because I told him that "Sylvia Plath just really gets me." I'm still sort of the same way. I'll read a book that will make me feel some kind of way, or it will perfectly reflect how I am already feeling, and it just seems so much more efficient to show that book as my mirror than to have an actual conversation. If you are my friend now, you know any gift from me will be a book. I will have thought about it for a long time, or I will have set it aside for you for weeks or months, because I want you to read something that makes you feel seen, that shows you I see you. Right now, the book Flying Solo by Linda Holmes had made a lot of rounds between my friends because I keep gifting it; it is perfect for people who are a bit odd and also deeply kind, and who love a deep dive into something completely random like duck decoys (and I can't think of a way to better describe my dearest friends). Books just keep getting better. I didn't have a lot of books growing up that reflected what it meant to be Vietnamese American. Now there are books like Tastes Like War and Stay True that remind me so much of my own family stories. And even the silliness of Crazy Rich Asians allows me celebrate over-the-top Asian success. In the end, books are words, right? Some of them contain the right words. I keep reading because the best books contain the right words for the exact moment I am in. I can still be a bit quiet in person, so I'll let the books do the talking.

Expand full comment

"Some of them contain the right words" is such a perfect way to put it. I have read Anne so many times since the first time at age 8 or 9, and there's always something different that stands out to me as I get older, something that sticks with me.

Expand full comment

I reread many of the Anne series when we had moved to Denver for 3 months, from Australia. I had 3 kids under 7 and immediately, joyously, joined the local library which had the most extraordinary children's section I have ever seen--as big as my entire local library at home. Americans know how to do libraries! I take my hat off. When I first approached the membership desk, I nervously proffered my Australian driver's licence for ID, saying 'King Supers wouldn't take it' and the librarians just smiled and said, 'But we're the library.'

Expand full comment

"But we're the library." Hearing about the children's section makes me smile. My family spent so many hours at the library when I was little and it has such a special place in my heart!

When I moved to Long Island eight years ago, I was really struggling to make it feel my home. After a few months, I got a library card and it didn't immediately make everything better, but I felt a little more belonging.

Expand full comment

Lovely :) We still all remember that library in Broomfield Denver with much affection. My youngest, 2 at the time, would immediately make for the enormous soft toy duck that she would carry around in a headlock. It was such a happy place.

Expand full comment

i relate to this so much <3 thank you sharing this, and so beautifully.

Expand full comment

Glad you can relate.

Expand full comment

I just borrowed Flying Solo from the library because of your recommendation. It sounds right up my alley. Thank you for sharing!!

Expand full comment

I hope you like it!

Expand full comment

I completely lost my ability to finish a book during the first year of the pandemic. As a lifelong (obsessive) reader I felt both grief and a little shame for having lost such a fundamental part of my personhood. In order to fill the hole, I turned to audiobooks. I listened to SO many audiobooks-- many of which were books I never would have bought or borrowed from the library. Some I listened to carefully and attentively, others I used to quiet the noise in my head. Then I started borrowing books in large quantities from my neighborhood "Little Free Libraries." Every day I walked different routes picking out books. I'd start one and see if I was hooked in the first 25 pages. If not, it was returned. This jump started my reading again. It was low pressure and low stakes and that worked for me. Now I am abroad and reading using a Kindle (my first). I borrow a bunch of books from the library at once, choosing a wide range that might work for my given mood or attention level. If a book doesn't pull me in, I return it and move to the next. I never used to read this way. I committed to books and finished them. Now I am a fickle reader and that's ok.

Expand full comment

I saw something about this somewhere - after the pandemic people stopped reading things that don’t grab them. I think we all have a sense of urgency about living life now and on some fundamental level we don’t want to waste time. I love your LFL idea!

Expand full comment

I certainly feel this. I used to be resolutely completionist about finishing any book I started, even if I wasn't enjoying it. I am no longer that way. Life is too short and there are too many other books out there.

Expand full comment

For me it’s less about not wanting to waste time, and more that there are just SO many mental distractions that it takes an extra special book to suck me in. The world is on fire, it feels, and if the book isn’t especially gripping then my mind easily wanders to my worldly concerns.

Expand full comment

I realize some neighborhoods' LFLs are brimming with books, while others languish. I approached my local library's Friends group, which gets donations and runs a couple big book sales every year. What happens to the books that don't sell? They didn't want to take them back to their warehouse, so I was allowed to come and fill up my car with a few boxes of unsold books after their October sale ended, and I've been distributing them to LFLs ever since on my daily walks. It's a way to share my love of reading AND get some exercise!

Expand full comment

I'm a big magazine reader, practically it's own dinosaur category, as the ones I read keep shutting down! I keep a few that I've read in my car, and when I run errands I pull up the LFL app on my phone and try to hit a location I've not been to before and drop them off.

Expand full comment

A few days ago, I found a 2007 copy of Martha Stewart Living in a LFL, and was shocked at how HUGE it was. Several hundred pages long. I miss big magazines!!

Expand full comment

It honestly makes me sad that so many of the magazines I used to read recently (Oprah, Entertainment Weekly, now Allure) are gone. I tried so hard to get my kids into magazines, too, and once they grew out of Zoobooks and American Girl, that was it :(

Expand full comment

How fantastic!!

Expand full comment

Oh my gosh Belle - I subscribe by this rule too and it has TOTALLY transformed how I read. I used to feel weirdly obligated that I HAD to read what I started. But I now live by the 20 page rule. I start it, if by page 20 it hasn't captured my attention I return it to the library, or if I bought it I pass it on to a friend, neighbour or a little free library. Totally game changing.

Expand full comment

Yes! Aside from the actual library, a LFL near the beach on vacation pulled me in with a wonderful YA book. I think it felt lower stakes since I was at the beach but reminded me it’s great to read for fun.

Expand full comment

What a terrific strategy for Little Free Library books! My neighbourhood brims with LFLs and I am constantly bringing home more books to add to the TBR mountain. Twenty-five pages to get hooked or the book goes back. I will keep that in mind.

Expand full comment

That LFL idea is fantastic

Expand full comment

I started reading - obsessively (and I don't use the description lightly) - when my daughter was about 18 months old. We live in a rural town, and the only free thing to do with a toddler on a Saturday morning was go to the library and let her play with the toy train set. I started checking out books. At first, I started reading books because I wanted to follow all the parenting "expert" advice to be a role model and get off my phone when I was with my kid. But watching a young kid all day is so, so boring. Reading became my escape. Now, almost six years later, I am always reading a book - to the point that my husband complains that I read too much.

My employer required me to come back to the office and won't allow hybrid or work from home. And sitting at my desk, staring at a computer all day is so, so mind-numbing. I used to help pass the time by reading Twitter to "look busy." But I quit Twitter the day of the Capitol insurrection. I just couldn't stomach it anymore. So I bought a Kindle, and now I read on the sly during my slow times at work. It's like my little act of rebellion against The Man for wasting my time working in an uncomfortable office.

I read almost 100 books this year, mostly romantic comedies. I read to feel good, so I don't read a lot of horror or suspense. I do try to read contemporary literature and nonfiction, even if it's sometimes a slog to get through, because I think it's good to study other writers, learn new cultures and pick up a few life lessons.

Expand full comment

are you reading in your internet browser? I admit, sometimes I do it at work when it's very slow, I keep a tab open with a book and try to get through a chapter or two instead of endlessly scrolling reddit.

Expand full comment

yes, I sometimes pull up Kindle on my browser. But I found it hard on my eyes, for some reason, so I bought a physical Kindle. It's small and not very noticeable on my desk. Definitely not different than my colleagues, who are constantly looking at their phones during work hours. (That sound judgey, but I'm not. We have to do what we have to do to pass the hours when it's slow.)

Expand full comment

I’ve got a 3 month old baby right now. After she was born, reading naturally took a backseat, but now that I’ve figured out baby wearing and we have a little bit more of a routine, I’ve prioritized reading as much as I can prioritize it. If my baby is napping on me in the carrier, rather than scroll my phone, I try to read. It’s helped me maintain my identity outside of newly becoming Mother and it’s really important to me.

Expand full comment

I did the same! And I have such sweet memories of it now. I was a huge reader and everyone told me that I'd never read again once my baby was born. But once we got into a little routine after a few weeks, I'd let him nap on me and I'd just sit quietly and read and listen to him breathe. It was time well spent, both for my brain and my heart. Enjoy those connected moments!

Expand full comment

Whenever my babies were little (under 2, honestly) I'd load up my Kindle with young adult dystopian fiction (Hunger Games, Divergent, Uglies, etc.) and just plow through those when I was nursing or napping on me. I was too tired for literature, but LOVED diving into a YA series.

Expand full comment

Yes! I felt the same way. I got Libby on my phone so I could read while the baby was eating, sleeping on me, or otherwise making it impossible to move.

Expand full comment

I was the kid who read everything, even multiple times. But at some point I stopped reading for probably ten years or maybe more. I had little kids and unmedicated depression and anxiety, and I spent a lot of time on early 2000s moms’ forums.

I read a book here and there, mostly for work, and I did read the whole Harry Potter series when my daughter read it.

But then I moved 700 miles away, my job that I moved for was awful, and one of my best friends died suddenly. Two things got me through: the whole series of Veronica Mars, which I had never seen, and murder mystery novels. Specifically, the In Death series that has like 55 books in it so far.

I started reading other stuff too, and enjoying it like when I was a kid. It stuck.

My point with this Ted Talk is that as AHP said, reading should be FUN. There are no rules about it and sometimes it goes away for a while, and if we’re lucky, we find it again out of survival or desperation or whatever.

Expand full comment

The time I really lost reading was when I was writing my own book. I didn’t even realize it until after the proofreading stage when it was finally out of my hands. I read an inordinate amount for research. (Last year was the first time I ever kept count--I’ll probably never do it again, was just curious--and I read 86 books; I didn’t keep track of articles and essays and podcasts but it was also a lot.) When I was finally done with the process, I picked up a nighttime read, a YA fantasy, for the first time in two years, and immediately got engrossed. I’ve been hooked on books my whole life and still literally thought, “I forgot I actually like reading!”

There are a lot of questions in this post that could probably use a newsletter from each respondent! Short answer--regular breaks from the internet entirely have become something I really rely on. Even if it’s not a reading vacation, if it’s something like camping, it makes me aware of how the combination of online and on devices keeps my brain in a bit of a fever. Being offline and away from devices is grounding in a very essential way. The more I do it, the more I think it’s important for everyone to have access to something that helps them reset and get in touch with their own selves and with the physical world around us, especially the non-human one.

Expand full comment

A bit of a fever. Well said.

Expand full comment

Having recently had to start going back to in-person work in the office a few days a week, carrying a book to read on my commute has been one of the "treat rituals" I've set up to make it celebratory and fun. I make it dedicated reading time, with no podcasts or music, and there is enough of a station-to-station chunk of time that I can make a little dent in my book on each leg of the journey. I also love making a little pencil mark next to things that leap out as I read, and sharing those with my husband as part of my "stories from my day" when I get home at night.

Expand full comment

+1 for writing in books! Allowing myself to write in the books I own has been a great way to train my attention, and I think also helps me learn better if I'm reading something dense.

Expand full comment

totally! also, if a book becomes a keeper that I reread later on, there's something really neat about coming across my little smiley-faces or "I loved this" or underlined bits

Expand full comment

I was a voracious reader as a child, reading and re-reading books. It's funny, looking back I have vivid memories of reading in the car, while my brother played soccer, at the kitchen table, etc, but I don't remember carrying books anywhere- they seem to just appear out of nowhere. I stopped reading for fun in college and after law school could barely fathom the idea of doing any more reading in my spare time after all the hours spend reading opinions. As a law firm associate, I longed to get back into it, but could never find the mental space to get immersed in fiction again. Tying into some of AHP's other frequent themes, my job and society in general generated enormous pressure for me to be efficient and productive at all times and novels just didn't seem worth the time. I did read some narrative non-fiction during this period, which I justified to myself as educational. I also struggled internally with the shift to e-books. During the second year of the pandemic and with a small child I finally started reading novels again on my iphone kindle-app no-less because it was something I could do while my son insisted I stay within 5 feet of him at all times. It took time, but now I feel like I'm addicted to reading again and I LOVE IT. It's such a joy to lose myself in a story again. Truly one of the few things I do for fun right now. And I have this group to thank for the terrific book recs and the Libby app for making it easy to move from one book to the next.

Expand full comment

I'm in the throes of finals as a middle-aged MA English student. My kids need everything, my students need everything, my eldest child is in Ireland right now, pouting, and I just feel like reading actual books seems like an impossible luxury. HOWEVER. I love this newsletter because so much of my identity is not just wrapped in being A Reader, but so much of how I understand the world comes from things I have read. This question you have posed this week really resonates. I was so unable to read anything for a while (also a person who lost the ability to sustain any real reading during the pandemic), but I figured out finally that reading on my phone allowed me to begin making my way back to the kind of reader I was before. I usually just go for sort of popcorn-y, escapist reading on there, and it's great. I don't feel like weird guilt that comes with endless social media doom-scrolling, but it also does not completely take over my mind the way reading physical copies of books has always done for me. I dislike being interrupted while I'm reading, and if someone in my household sees me curled up with a book, and they bother me for something that can wait, or that they can do themselves or whatever, it bugs me and then I feel guilty for being irritable, which makes reading a book into some other kind of weird decadent thing that I shouldn't be doing. But reading on the phone? Psshhh, that's not the case at all. Go ahead, ask me the thing that you can do for yourself. I'm just sitting here with my phone anyway. I guess all this is to say, somehow, I've acquired a lot of guilt about reading, which feels terrible to consider. Now that I've thought about it, though, it's clear that it will continue to be something that is in my mind and I'll be able to sort through it. Also, I'm not going to ask for Hua Hsu's book for Christmas, I'm just going to order it right now. I love all his other writing and I've been looking forward to this book for quite a while.

Expand full comment

reading is incredibly meaningful to me. i learned english when i entered public school, and i remember burning hot with embarrassment when my second grade teacher announced to the class that i had read a novella on my own, bunnicula (about a vampiric bunny). i remember staring straight down at my desk while she praised me because the two blonde girls next to me were glaring, but i also felt this molten core of pride. i stopped devouring books like i did as a kid once phones became smarter, but i never stopped reading. i started to have sleeping issues and discovered that they almost always went away when i read before bed. the pandemic actually kicked up my reading habit. i worked for lululemon and they paid us for three plus months when the pandemic first began while

our stores were shut down. i was living my dream life of reading books, cooking food, and walking long walks every day.

i have a goodreads where i track my reading now. i’m on book 46 of 50. usually i make my goal much less and exceed it but i decided to just go for the big number this year. sometimes i find myself reading a shorter book just to catch back up on my pace. however, if i need to finish a book sometimes i’ll give myself the afternoon on a weekend to finish it and it feels indulgent but not BAD. like it’s brain candy. next year my goal is to read better— i’ve always wanted to keep a card system of what i loved about a book, etc, almost like a log for school. i read so many books now i forget the plots. i also can’t read speculative fiction before bed because the combination of being tired/world building is a disaster haha. so i’d like to dedicate more afternoon weekends to those books. i am an actor, but sometimes i dream of being a librarian.

Expand full comment

i also wanted to mention that when the pandemic first began i noticed my attention span was so tiny. i could only read for 15 minutes at a time without wanting to check my phone. it took practice but it got better. also, one tiny hit of weed helped. not enough to knock me out but enough to make tedium interesting.

Expand full comment

I love Bunnicula!

Expand full comment

So do I! And the sequels: Howliday Inn and The Celery Stalks at Midnight (a title that still makes me giggle).

Expand full comment

There’s a graphic novel adaptation of Bunnicula that I just read this week and it is a delight!

Expand full comment

OMG, I must have it!

Expand full comment

I have one significant tattoo and it is an owl and a stack of books and banner that reads “bibliophile” so yeah reading has always been the most important to me. I used to average about 100 books a year, mixed genres, usually more than one at a time. Pandemic hit - 2020 I read over 250 books. Mostly romance, but I needed all of the escape I could get. And then I went almost an entire year without being able to finish a book. The Great Slump almost broke me, a book would grab me here or there, but mostly it felt like...everything just slid off my brain. It’s coming back. I don’t think I’ll ever read as much as I did in 2020, I don’t think I want or need to. But I have been able to focus on fantasy and mysteries again, books with more plot than trope and higher stakes than a first kiss. It feels really really good, and the only thing that did it was time and acceptance. I didn’t force myself to read or fight with my attention span, the most skittish of kittens these days. I returned to authors I’ve always loved, stopped keeping track entirely to ease off the competitive/comparison stuff, quit scrolling bookstagram and booktok for the newest shiny and just let myself get lost in a story again. I’ve never taken reading for granted, but I do appreciate it in a deeper way now.

Expand full comment

Reading and privacy are somehow connected for me. I notice that my favorite memories of childhood reading were when I could wake up before everyone else and read quietly while the house was silent.

As a preteen I mostly read fanfiction and manga. In high school I reclaimed my book reader-identity: I loved most of the books I read in school and went on to double major in English and journalism. My favorite kind of learning was always just reading in a book and taking notes in the margins, so I took a lot of joy from that practice. (Never went to grad school, so maybe that's why it's still golden in my memory!)

I didn't have a big "rut," but I did notice my relationship to reading changed in college. Goodreads really fucked me up. I kept a shelf-per-year and noticed I was always trying to outdo myself. This was encouraging me to leave books I really wanted to read aside, in favor of shorter ones that could pump up the numbers. Agh!

The first thing I did was stop rating books. The more I thought about it the more insane the idea of rating a book seemed: as if the point of a book is to meet-or-exceed expectations; as if we could do the same for books as we do with hotels and restaurants. But that still didn't really cut it. So I had to quit Goodreads for good. Now I just keep a list on my phone of "books and essays read" for a given year--no counting, just titles. I include long essays because I like to read big books of theoretical essays, but they literally take years to finish! Quitting Goodreads has gotten rid of all that optimization-feeling.

It has the other benefit of making my reading life feel more private to me again, which was more important than I thought!

Expand full comment

I quit Goodreads for the same reasons. I felt like, "You can't tell me what to do!" I like tracking my reading - I keep a spreadsheet - but I don't like that little banner telling me I'm six books behind or whatever.

Expand full comment

This resonates. I associate reading with privacy too. Not only the act, but the whole thing. It is intensely private for me. I don't share much while I'm reading, I don't want to discuss it with people afterwards (except one on one, occasionally) and my interpretations, what I've gained or understood are mine. I can't see the point in sharing, really because someone else brings their own experience to it, and take away something different. For that reason too, I don't join book clubs, nor read Good Reads 'reviews'. They are random opinions, which would never influence me towards buying or not buying a book. Sometimes I do rate books (only 5*) by small time or indie authors only, because they need it to sell books and I'm sympathetic to that.

Expand full comment

Yes! I am reconnecting with books for the first time in a long time. I am coming out of having a small dependent child (who is now 7) shortly after medical school and residency.

The only way it happens now is that she is reading more on her own and her only “homework” is 300 minutes of reading a month. So we go to the library together and then have Family Reading Time. I also have 90% quit social media. Amazing the shift in my brain when I spend the time reading a book rather than news and doom scrolling.

Expand full comment

Agreed about social media. It really is hard to make space in your brain for both. I've replaced almost all of my social media consumption with Substacks and other newsletters, which don't take up nearly as much idle time, and encourage reading. Also made for an unexpectedly nice Sunday morning ritual: two Substacks I follow publish on Sunday mornings, which gives me this nice reading to do while I have tea. Yay substack! I so much hope they don't ruin this app..!

Expand full comment

yes! i uninstall social media apps from my phone regularly and it’s amazing how much more time i have. sometimes i will reinstall when i intentionally want time to pass quickly, like on a layover or something.

Expand full comment

Reading is Life! Like many other posters, I’ve been a lifelong voracious reader. My mom taught me to read before I entered kindergarten, and there hasn’t been a day since that I haven’t had my nose in book. In high school I was in the dance/drill team and we performed at the football halftime. I would bring my book and read it in the stands while others cheered on the game. I could find a way to read anywhere.

Post-2016 my reading habit became a bit subsumed by a news addiction. By 2020, I was full-on doom-scrolling. This was taking up a lot time and making me feel constant angst. Over time, I was able to quit cold turkey those habits, and I replaced them with reading. I doubled the number of books I read in a year. I joined an incredible online book club in August 2020 that has fortified my reading life and brought me new friendships. Reading was my social life during the two-year pandemic.

This year, one of my goals was to create an intimate in-person reading community. I started a literary salon (“Ladies Who Lit”), and we meet every other month at my house for a delicious lunch and book swap. On the off month, we’ve been getting together in the community for an activity. Yesterday was our salon event and it was delightful in every way. Each person went home with at least 4 books, and we had a Secret Santa gift exchange.

Reading has been a great gift in my life. It’s always been by my side, and is now how I build community.

Expand full comment